Come early January, while everything up here is well frozen, the Reddess and I will be chill-axing in San Diego at the annual meeting of the American Association of Law Schools. While there is much to be learned and important contacts to be made at such meetings, it's also a bit of a boondoggle.
I've blogged before on a call by certain individuals and organizations in the legal academy to boycott one of the hotels at which AALS has booked rooms and may hold events, the Manchester Grand Hyatt.
The reason for the boycott is that the owner of the Hyatt, Doug Manchester (more accurately, Manchester Financial), has contributed to the campaign to amend the California Constitution to ban same-sex marriage. To hold a meeting at his hotel, according to proponents of the boycott, would violate the anti-discrimination policies of the AALS and the various other organizations involved in the meeting.
There is much that is wrong with this. The hotel itself doesn't discriminate against gays and lesbians so the boycott is solely concerned with the politics and speech of its owner. It is scandalous, I think, for an academic organization purportedly devoted to an open debate and the full exploration of ideas to boycott someone simply because some of its members don't care for his ideas. It is particularly ironic that one of the principal organizers of the boycott teaches at Villanova, a Catholic institution that I suspect does not provide domestic partner benefits and is part of a church that not only opposes same-sex marriage, but regards it as a sin. Apparently conscience does not require foregoing a paycheck.
But that's not what I am interested in here.
The AALS sent an e-mail around today announcing that it will hold no events at the Grand Hyatt, placing them all in the San Deigo Marriott - the other hotel at which rooms for the meeting are being held. Apparently, the AALS contracts with the Grand Hyatt and Marriott "provide that each hotel reserve a block of guest rooms, and leave to the AALS the choice of where to locate the AALS Registration, Exhibit Hall, Section Programs, Presidential Programs, and House of Representatives meetings." The e-mail announces that the organization "will honor our contracts with both hotels, and we have exercised our option to hold all AALS events at the Marriott to ensure the maximum participation by our members. " In other words, the AALS thinks that it is honoring, insofar as it contracts permit, the boycott.
That's shameful. While I understand the desire to "maximize participation," a scholarly organization ought not cater to those who cannot tolerate opposing points of view.
But here's the beauty part. Doug Manchester owns the San Diego Marriott as well. Neither the boycotters nor the AALS appear to have done their homework.
Thus, assuming that the conscience of the boycotters requires that they not the only patronize Manchester properties, the only way to "do justice" is to stay home in January.
UPDATE: But maybe the boycotters did get it right. Although Manchester's website lists the Marriott as one of the Group's properties, the San Diego Business Jourmal reports that he sold his interest in the hotel last spring for 93 million dollars that he could "cash out" at any time (does that mean that he still retains his interest with the ability to put it to the buyer), but part of the consideration was a stake in the buyer so he retains an interest, albeit a very small one (2.5%) in the Marriott. I guess that's not enough to "taint" the hotel.
"I think I was trying to suggest something about the duality of man, sir ... the Jungian thing, sir." Private Joker, Full Metal Jacket
Monday, August 18, 2008
Sunday, August 17, 2008
The Scattering
As Irishfest winds down, enjoy Sinead O'Connor and the Chieftans performing the classic "Foggy Dew."
Or the Dubliners and the Pogues collaborating on "The Irish Rover."
There are probably more people that think the "Whiskey in the Jar" is a song "by" Thin Lizzy or Metallica, than know it is a traditional Irish folk song of many variations. Here's U2 performing it live (and, following, I think the Thin Lizzy version which was a big hit in Ireland):
And, finally, because I said I would, here are my favorite misguided - but loveable -Fenians singing the politically naive (and somewhat didactic) "James Connolly:"
Or the Dubliners and the Pogues collaborating on "The Irish Rover."
There are probably more people that think the "Whiskey in the Jar" is a song "by" Thin Lizzy or Metallica, than know it is a traditional Irish folk song of many variations. Here's U2 performing it live (and, following, I think the Thin Lizzy version which was a big hit in Ireland):
And, finally, because I said I would, here are my favorite misguided - but loveable -Fenians singing the politically naive (and somewhat didactic) "James Connolly:"
Friday, August 15, 2008
Inconvenient truths?
Paul Soglin is upset with right wingers for blaming poor educational results in MPS on the "parents." He implies that the argument is racially based and complains that it admits of no solution by which he means that it does not readily suggest an intervention by the government - something that all social problems apparently require.
But what if they're right? Soglin doesn't like the aesthetics or implications of the argument, but what if it turns out to be true? When I talk to friends and family members who are education scholars or who work at MPS (not many of whom are conservatives), I am unfailingly depressed. The reason is that two things seem almost certainly to be true. First, there is the weight of the evidence does not provide much hope for the idea that additional research will result in better results. Second, we probably can't expect urban school districts like MPS to do much better without changing the family environments of a large proportion of the students. Indeed, it seems, much of the additional resources that urban districts call for seem to be needed so the school can do for a child what her family has not.
The problem is that government does a lousy imitation of a family. It may take a village to raise a child - I think it does - but the state is not the village.
There is, it seems to me, a reason that communities that do not have a history of dysfunctional families are marred by them today. It doesn't seem to be a simple function of racism and poverty and the absence of social programs because the degree of dysfunction has increased as both have decreased. Is it our increased laxity regarding sex and marriage? Is it the abandonment of poor neighborhoods by the black middle class?
The point seems to me that this stuff is important and it doesn't help to exclude certain perspectives because they are deemed racially insensitive or to assume that the measure of policy is involvement by the state combined with good intentions.
On a related point, Paul, in complaining about the parks in Madison, asserts that the size of state and local governments has not kept up with inflation. Is that true? It's not true nationally, is Wisconsin an exception. Do we have trouble maintaining the parks in Milwaukee County because conservatives have starved government or has government starved itself with unaffordable benefit packages that have devoted enormous resources to people who no longer work for it?
But what if they're right? Soglin doesn't like the aesthetics or implications of the argument, but what if it turns out to be true? When I talk to friends and family members who are education scholars or who work at MPS (not many of whom are conservatives), I am unfailingly depressed. The reason is that two things seem almost certainly to be true. First, there is the weight of the evidence does not provide much hope for the idea that additional research will result in better results. Second, we probably can't expect urban school districts like MPS to do much better without changing the family environments of a large proportion of the students. Indeed, it seems, much of the additional resources that urban districts call for seem to be needed so the school can do for a child what her family has not.
The problem is that government does a lousy imitation of a family. It may take a village to raise a child - I think it does - but the state is not the village.
There is, it seems to me, a reason that communities that do not have a history of dysfunctional families are marred by them today. It doesn't seem to be a simple function of racism and poverty and the absence of social programs because the degree of dysfunction has increased as both have decreased. Is it our increased laxity regarding sex and marriage? Is it the abandonment of poor neighborhoods by the black middle class?
The point seems to me that this stuff is important and it doesn't help to exclude certain perspectives because they are deemed racially insensitive or to assume that the measure of policy is involvement by the state combined with good intentions.
On a related point, Paul, in complaining about the parks in Madison, asserts that the size of state and local governments has not kept up with inflation. Is that true? It's not true nationally, is Wisconsin an exception. Do we have trouble maintaining the parks in Milwaukee County because conservatives have starved government or has government starved itself with unaffordable benefit packages that have devoted enormous resources to people who no longer work for it?
Thursday, August 14, 2008
Old old news
I think that the release of OSS personnel files is going to create some fascinating reading but I was a little surprised by the media twist that at least implies that celebrities like Julia Child and baseball player Moe Berg have been newly identified as OSS agents. I seem to have known about Julia Child for years. Last summer, I visited the Spy Museum in DC (its better than it sounds) and they were pictures of Child and Berg.
Tuesday, August 12, 2008
Back to the Packers' Future
I have to. As someone who thinks that the Packers made the wrong call on Brett Favre, I was happy to see the crowd at Lambeau give Aaron Rodgers a standing ovation when he ran on the field. The mistake, if there was one, was not his and what's done is done.
I must also admit that he was very impressive. He did miss a wide open James Jones, but it also seemed that Jones did a poor job of adjusting to the ball. Jones did bail him out a bit on the touchdown pass (which was high), but that's one of the things he has going for him. He has a great corp of recievers. (Jordy Nelson also looked promising.)The inteception, of course, was not his fault. Rodgers moved the ball up and down the field and, while it was an exhibition, the Bengals don't have a great defense and I am sure that what he faced was very vanilla, this game could not have gone much better for Rodgers.
On the other hand, if he goes down, there may be trouble. Brohm did not play well, although I was cautiously impressed by Matt Flynn.
Finally, the Packers first string defense was dominant. All in all, the game inflated my expectations.
I must also admit that he was very impressive. He did miss a wide open James Jones, but it also seemed that Jones did a poor job of adjusting to the ball. Jones did bail him out a bit on the touchdown pass (which was high), but that's one of the things he has going for him. He has a great corp of recievers. (Jordy Nelson also looked promising.)The inteception, of course, was not his fault. Rodgers moved the ball up and down the field and, while it was an exhibition, the Bengals don't have a great defense and I am sure that what he faced was very vanilla, this game could not have gone much better for Rodgers.
On the other hand, if he goes down, there may be trouble. Brohm did not play well, although I was cautiously impressed by Matt Flynn.
Finally, the Packers first string defense was dominant. All in all, the game inflated my expectations.
Desecration Mountain
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, sitting en banc, recently decided a interesting religious freedom case. In Navajo Nation v. U.S. Forest Service, American Indians sought to prohibit the federal government from allowing the use of artificial snow for skiing on a portion of a public mountain sacred in their religion. Appartently the government planned to use recycled wastewater, which contains 0.0001% human waste,and would, therefore,desecrate the entire mountain, deprecate their religious ceremonies, and injure their religious sensibilities. This, they argued, would violate the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
The RFRA, in general, allows plaintiffs to challenge government practices that substantially burden the exercise of religion. If there is a substantial burden, the government must demonstrate that the burden is the least restrictive means to achieve a compelling interest. It was enacted in response to a Supreme Court decision that said, essentiall, no such claim could be brought against neutral laws of general applicability under the Constitution's free exercise clause.
The court (over three dissents) rejected the challenge. That doesn't surprise me, but I am interested in the court's reasoning. It found that there was not substantial burden - essentially because the only harm to the Navajos was to their "subjective spiritual experience."
I can understand the attraction of this position. The majority obviously feared the slippery slope and the result was consistent with an earlier Supreme Court decision under the free exercise clause. But does it make sense to say that a government action that desecrates a sacred object does not substantially burden religious practice? The court claimed that the Navajos would still have access to the mountain for worship, but was the court in any position to contradict the Navajos' claim that their worship was substantially impaired? Normally, courts don't second guess litigants claims about what their religion requires.
It is, I think, the fear of this type of case that underlies the Supreme Court's rule in the free exercise context. It seems to me that the Navajos' religious practices have been substantially burdened, but requiring the government to demonstrate a compelling interest in cases like this would be unworkable.
The RFRA, in general, allows plaintiffs to challenge government practices that substantially burden the exercise of religion. If there is a substantial burden, the government must demonstrate that the burden is the least restrictive means to achieve a compelling interest. It was enacted in response to a Supreme Court decision that said, essentiall, no such claim could be brought against neutral laws of general applicability under the Constitution's free exercise clause.
The court (over three dissents) rejected the challenge. That doesn't surprise me, but I am interested in the court's reasoning. It found that there was not substantial burden - essentially because the only harm to the Navajos was to their "subjective spiritual experience."
I can understand the attraction of this position. The majority obviously feared the slippery slope and the result was consistent with an earlier Supreme Court decision under the free exercise clause. But does it make sense to say that a government action that desecrates a sacred object does not substantially burden religious practice? The court claimed that the Navajos would still have access to the mountain for worship, but was the court in any position to contradict the Navajos' claim that their worship was substantially impaired? Normally, courts don't second guess litigants claims about what their religion requires.
It is, I think, the fear of this type of case that underlies the Supreme Court's rule in the free exercise context. It seems to me that the Navajos' religious practices have been substantially burdened, but requiring the government to demonstrate a compelling interest in cases like this would be unworkable.
Take a pill
Barack Obama says that "American-made motorcycles like Harleys don’t matter to John McCain."
Why, you ask?
Because he didn't support legislation requiring the government to buy American-made motorcycles. He actually thought that the government ought to buy motorcycles based on price and quality. Maybe that would be Harleys. Maybe not. He just wanted government to get the best deal for taxpayers' money.
So often we are faced with arguments that, if you don't support the idea that government should mandate a particular outcome, then you must oppose that outcome/ This reflects an historical move toward, as Hugh Heclo puts it in this marvelous essay Christianity and American Democracy, that the "one thing of supreme inportance in politics is government policy" and that democracy ought to entail "commitment to a never-ending policy agenda of social problem-solving."
But not everything that is potentially good should be mandated and not every good outcome is best acheived by some kind of fiat from above. It's not true that, if the government does it, it won't be done.
I took a few minutes this morning to surf around our local blogs and found an example close to home.
In a post largely dedicated to the idea that "Republicans are bad," Jay Bullock offers, as an example, the fact that conservative columnist Patrick McIlheran, following an accident in which someone was killed by a tire flying off a truck, was not convinced that more government inspections were essential. Jay's summary is that the "right" opposes "any requirements that corporations try not to, you know, kill people ...."
Really? I guess that politics must be very important to you if you think those who disagree with you want to let corporations kill people.; if you think that, in the absence of inspections, trucking companies are actually indifferent to whether tires fly off their vehicles, disrupting the movement of freight, bringing lawsuits, and killing people.
So John McCain hates Harleys. Patrick McIlheran wants people to die.
Why, you ask?
Because he didn't support legislation requiring the government to buy American-made motorcycles. He actually thought that the government ought to buy motorcycles based on price and quality. Maybe that would be Harleys. Maybe not. He just wanted government to get the best deal for taxpayers' money.
So often we are faced with arguments that, if you don't support the idea that government should mandate a particular outcome, then you must oppose that outcome/ This reflects an historical move toward, as Hugh Heclo puts it in this marvelous essay Christianity and American Democracy, that the "one thing of supreme inportance in politics is government policy" and that democracy ought to entail "commitment to a never-ending policy agenda of social problem-solving."
But not everything that is potentially good should be mandated and not every good outcome is best acheived by some kind of fiat from above. It's not true that, if the government does it, it won't be done.
I took a few minutes this morning to surf around our local blogs and found an example close to home.
In a post largely dedicated to the idea that "Republicans are bad," Jay Bullock offers, as an example, the fact that conservative columnist Patrick McIlheran, following an accident in which someone was killed by a tire flying off a truck, was not convinced that more government inspections were essential. Jay's summary is that the "right" opposes "any requirements that corporations try not to, you know, kill people ...."
Really? I guess that politics must be very important to you if you think those who disagree with you want to let corporations kill people.; if you think that, in the absence of inspections, trucking companies are actually indifferent to whether tires fly off their vehicles, disrupting the movement of freight, bringing lawsuits, and killing people.
So John McCain hates Harleys. Patrick McIlheran wants people to die.
Sunday, August 10, 2008
Celtic Rock, pt. 1
Now begins the week of Irishfest - a sacred time for the Reddess' Clan Cooley and my maternal Clan McDonald. So we need Irish rock. Let's start with the Corrs' performance of Jimi Hendrix' exquisite "Little Wing."
But Irish rock often has a harder edge and here is the Cranberries' "Zombie."
But I am supposed to be doing older stuff and Irish rock often has a spritual character. In the early 80s, U2 took an iconic name in rock and roll and gave it an entirely different spin. This is "Gloria" from a concert in Dortmund in 1984.
Back then - and now - U2 ended their set with "40" - an adaptation of the Psalm 40. Here's the old song performed on the group's latest tour.
Next week, I may go all Sinead O'Connor and Black 47 on you.
But Irish rock often has a harder edge and here is the Cranberries' "Zombie."
But I am supposed to be doing older stuff and Irish rock often has a spritual character. In the early 80s, U2 took an iconic name in rock and roll and gave it an entirely different spin. This is "Gloria" from a concert in Dortmund in 1984.
Back then - and now - U2 ended their set with "40" - an adaptation of the Psalm 40. Here's the old song performed on the group's latest tour.
Next week, I may go all Sinead O'Connor and Black 47 on you.
Saturday, August 09, 2008
John and Cindy and John and Rielle
What should be the political consequences to John Edwards of his admitted affair with Rielle Hunter. Let's put aside for a moment, the fact that he lied about it and his odd claim that he had been 99% honest, I don't want to get into the "lying about sex" exception to the general admonition for honesty.
Should this end his political career?
Before conservatives and Republicans quickly assent, they ought to remember that John McCain may have done the same thing. Whether or not he took up with Cindy Hensley before his marriage to Carol McCain had ended in fact (if not in law as it most certainly had not), he apparently has admitted to running around with other women during that period of time. If Edwards career is over, why wasn't McCain's?
I actually don't think Edwards' political career should be over because of his dalliances. (There are, however, many other reasons to end it.) But I am reluctant to say that it doesn't matter or that it is entirely private - at least not at the level of the Presidency.
Certainly it does say something about his character although I dislike the part of our politics that destroys otherwise good people for getting caught in a piece of bad business which is comparable to what many others are guilty of but not caught at. I appreciate the we cannot know what goes on in someone else's marriage and that the cause of this type of thing can be complex. I also understand that we are flawed and no one of us is without sin (or, as we call them today, "mistakes.")
But, in a way, that is why it can't be ignored. It is hard to do the right thing. Fidelity is difficult and marriage, while it is a great blessing, is a lot of work. Yet it is vital to society. This was a grave betrayal of Elizabeth Edwards and the Edwards children and, in a way, of Rielle Hunter and, if it is his, her child. When engaged in by someone aspiring to the Presidency or Vice Presidency, it is scandalous in the theological sense of the word, i.e., it offends moral standards in a way that may discredit them or become a stumbling block to others.
A HuffPo blogger asks whether, in light of that affair, "Edwards care[s] less about poor people today than he did yesterday?" He notes that history has revealed extramarital affairs on the part of other leaders and suggests that they had nothing to do with how they governed.
Is it just that they did not get caught? Is it just that it was long ago?
In part, yes, it is. Edwards has modeled behavior that has been and is disastrous for poor people in particular. It is behavior with public consequences and, in public figures, must be condemned. One of the ways that happens is that he gets his time in the wilderness. In someone standing for our highest office, respect for doing the right thing seems to demand that John Edwards suffer public consequences for doing the wrong one.
In its immediate aftermath, John Edwards, just like Newt Gingrich, cannot expect to be a national leader. There may come a day, when a contrite Edwards, like Newt, can be rehabilitated. But it flouts our moral standards to reward him with a prominent speech at the Democratic convention or serious consideration for the Vice Presidency.
My guess is that Obama will do neither.
Should this end his political career?
Before conservatives and Republicans quickly assent, they ought to remember that John McCain may have done the same thing. Whether or not he took up with Cindy Hensley before his marriage to Carol McCain had ended in fact (if not in law as it most certainly had not), he apparently has admitted to running around with other women during that period of time. If Edwards career is over, why wasn't McCain's?
I actually don't think Edwards' political career should be over because of his dalliances. (There are, however, many other reasons to end it.) But I am reluctant to say that it doesn't matter or that it is entirely private - at least not at the level of the Presidency.
Certainly it does say something about his character although I dislike the part of our politics that destroys otherwise good people for getting caught in a piece of bad business which is comparable to what many others are guilty of but not caught at. I appreciate the we cannot know what goes on in someone else's marriage and that the cause of this type of thing can be complex. I also understand that we are flawed and no one of us is without sin (or, as we call them today, "mistakes.")
But, in a way, that is why it can't be ignored. It is hard to do the right thing. Fidelity is difficult and marriage, while it is a great blessing, is a lot of work. Yet it is vital to society. This was a grave betrayal of Elizabeth Edwards and the Edwards children and, in a way, of Rielle Hunter and, if it is his, her child. When engaged in by someone aspiring to the Presidency or Vice Presidency, it is scandalous in the theological sense of the word, i.e., it offends moral standards in a way that may discredit them or become a stumbling block to others.
A HuffPo blogger asks whether, in light of that affair, "Edwards care[s] less about poor people today than he did yesterday?" He notes that history has revealed extramarital affairs on the part of other leaders and suggests that they had nothing to do with how they governed.
Is it just that they did not get caught? Is it just that it was long ago?
In part, yes, it is. Edwards has modeled behavior that has been and is disastrous for poor people in particular. It is behavior with public consequences and, in public figures, must be condemned. One of the ways that happens is that he gets his time in the wilderness. In someone standing for our highest office, respect for doing the right thing seems to demand that John Edwards suffer public consequences for doing the wrong one.
In its immediate aftermath, John Edwards, just like Newt Gingrich, cannot expect to be a national leader. There may come a day, when a contrite Edwards, like Newt, can be rehabilitated. But it flouts our moral standards to reward him with a prominent speech at the Democratic convention or serious consideration for the Vice Presidency.
My guess is that Obama will do neither.
Thursday, August 07, 2008
Thompson and McCarthy must expect to lose this year
I hate it when people in public life insult your intelligence. The performance by Mark Murphy, Ted Thompson and Mike McCarthy at today's press conference was embarassing. Yes, we understand that, as of the end of Brett's meeting with McCarthy, there was no choice but to trade him. But the question is how things came to that. What we want to hear about is what happened in June. What we want to know is why, when Favre said he wanted to come back, the team did not react in the manner that any rational person would have. You mean we can have our Pro Bowl quarterback for another year? Outstanding! Let's talk. Your place or ours?
Instead they told him, in that mealy mouthed and meaningless phrase, we've moved on.
(As in, "you mean I'm not really fired? Well, thanks, but I've already filed for unemployment and everything and, you know, I've just moved on.")
Why did they do that?
There are only two answers to that question that are consistent with Thompson and McCarthy acting for the good of the team. One, they think that the Packers are not ready to win in 2008 and need to develop Rodgers for some point in the future when they will be or, two, they think Rodgers will be a better quarterback in 2008 than Favre.
The latter is silly, so it must be the former. They must think that the fact that they have won 18 of the last 22 games with the same guys who will be on the field this year was a fluke or a function of the schedule. They can't say it, but they don't expect a team that was a field goal away from the Super Bowl last year and which lost nobody that mattered to win this year.
Or at least that is the only rational explanation for their behavior.
Instead they told him, in that mealy mouthed and meaningless phrase, we've moved on.
(As in, "you mean I'm not really fired? Well, thanks, but I've already filed for unemployment and everything and, you know, I've just moved on.")
Why did they do that?
There are only two answers to that question that are consistent with Thompson and McCarthy acting for the good of the team. One, they think that the Packers are not ready to win in 2008 and need to develop Rodgers for some point in the future when they will be or, two, they think Rodgers will be a better quarterback in 2008 than Favre.
The latter is silly, so it must be the former. They must think that the fact that they have won 18 of the last 22 games with the same guys who will be on the field this year was a fluke or a function of the schedule. They can't say it, but they don't expect a team that was a field goal away from the Super Bowl last year and which lost nobody that mattered to win this year.
Or at least that is the only rational explanation for their behavior.
Broadway Brett
First, they had better protected themselves against the Jets trading or releasing Favre. The Journal-Sentinel says that''s "almost assured." The NFL Network reports that there is a poison pill that requires three firsts from the Jets if they trade him to the Vikings. Better be.
Second, is this a good move for Brett? This was a 4-12 team and two of those wins were over Miami. The coach is under fire. A big part of the problem does seem to have been their quarterback. They were 10-6 the year before and they do have Laveranues Coles and Thomas Jones. But they are in the same division with the Pats which may mean that the wild card is the best they can hope for.
Third, how well do Rodgers and the Packers have to play to save Ted Thompson's job? Say Favre takes the Jets to the wild card? Don't the Packers have to, at least, win the division? Can Favre play badly enough in New York to let Thompson off the hook? I am sure that Thompson wants to say that Rodgers ought to get a year to learn to settle in and that's not unreasonable, but it's not going to happen. Green Bay is a place where the fans would have given him that room, but Thompson has taken it away from him.
On the other hand, if Rodgers does play well and the Packers win, I don't think that a good season from Brett in New York matters that much - at least if it isn't dramatically better than what happens here.
Fourth, don't the Packers have to pick up a veteran backup? Please, God, not Chad Pennington.
Second, is this a good move for Brett? This was a 4-12 team and two of those wins were over Miami. The coach is under fire. A big part of the problem does seem to have been their quarterback. They were 10-6 the year before and they do have Laveranues Coles and Thomas Jones. But they are in the same division with the Pats which may mean that the wild card is the best they can hope for.
Third, how well do Rodgers and the Packers have to play to save Ted Thompson's job? Say Favre takes the Jets to the wild card? Don't the Packers have to, at least, win the division? Can Favre play badly enough in New York to let Thompson off the hook? I am sure that Thompson wants to say that Rodgers ought to get a year to learn to settle in and that's not unreasonable, but it's not going to happen. Green Bay is a place where the fans would have given him that room, but Thompson has taken it away from him.
On the other hand, if Rodgers does play well and the Packers win, I don't think that a good season from Brett in New York matters that much - at least if it isn't dramatically better than what happens here.
Fourth, don't the Packers have to pick up a veteran backup? Please, God, not Chad Pennington.
Tuesday, August 05, 2008
San Diego is a great place to protest
I am, notwithstanding the fact that I am old enough for my wonderful children to have wonderful children (but just barely!), new to full time employment as a legal academic. One of the things that comes with such employment is the opportunity to attend the annual meeting of the American Association of Law Schools (AALS) typically held in early January, between semesters. My first AALS meeting was last January in New York. I had a great time. Marquette hosted a reception with a chocolate fountain and blue and gold martinis. There was a great party at the Rainbow Room. Conservative profs met in the catacombs.
This academic year, the meeting is headquartered in San Diego (the Reddess approves!),and the main hotel is owned by a guy - devout Catholic - who has contributed to the referendum to ban same sex marriage in California. Certain sections of the AALS and of, there is no other way to describe it, anachronistic New Left organization known as the Society of American Law Teachers, want the AALS to move the meeting. If it doesn't, they say they won't attend events there. boycott the hotel. There is no allegation that the hotel discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation.
Of course, people can refuse to do business with persons whose politics they don't like. There are very few jurisdictions that prohibit discrimination on political grounds and such bans are, in my view, constitutionally suspect.
But this ups the political ante in a way that hampers civil discourse. Same sex marriage is something that, until very recently, few people had ever thought of. Now, in the view of some, opposition to it - for whatever reason - is so odious that opponents ought to be read out of civil society.
It reflects, I think, a desire to totalize politics. Robert Araujo, writing at Mirror of Justice, quotes Christopher Dawson's observation that the totalitarian state "is not satisfied with passive obedience; it demands full co-operation from the cradle to the grave… "
I find it particularly odd that legal scholars would take such a position. Would those who want to boycott the hotel walk out of panels including those who oppose same sex marriage or believe that the few cases that have found it to be constitutionally mandated were wrongly decided?
In the end, though, Orin Kerr at the Volokh Conspiracy may have the best take on this. "Whoever thought up a boycott that requires you to be in San Diego in January," he writes, "but forbids you to attend the panels has a keen sense of how to appeal to the academic mind."
Or to human nature in general.
This academic year, the meeting is headquartered in San Diego (the Reddess approves!),and the main hotel is owned by a guy - devout Catholic - who has contributed to the referendum to ban same sex marriage in California. Certain sections of the AALS and of, there is no other way to describe it, anachronistic New Left organization known as the Society of American Law Teachers, want the AALS to move the meeting. If it doesn't, they say they won't attend events there. boycott the hotel. There is no allegation that the hotel discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation.
Of course, people can refuse to do business with persons whose politics they don't like. There are very few jurisdictions that prohibit discrimination on political grounds and such bans are, in my view, constitutionally suspect.
But this ups the political ante in a way that hampers civil discourse. Same sex marriage is something that, until very recently, few people had ever thought of. Now, in the view of some, opposition to it - for whatever reason - is so odious that opponents ought to be read out of civil society.
It reflects, I think, a desire to totalize politics. Robert Araujo, writing at Mirror of Justice, quotes Christopher Dawson's observation that the totalitarian state "is not satisfied with passive obedience; it demands full co-operation from the cradle to the grave… "
I find it particularly odd that legal scholars would take such a position. Would those who want to boycott the hotel walk out of panels including those who oppose same sex marriage or believe that the few cases that have found it to be constitutionally mandated were wrongly decided?
In the end, though, Orin Kerr at the Volokh Conspiracy may have the best take on this. "Whoever thought up a boycott that requires you to be in San Diego in January," he writes, "but forbids you to attend the panels has a keen sense of how to appeal to the academic mind."
Or to human nature in general.
Out on a football limb
On Sunday night, it seemed to me that the over the top coverage of Brett Favre's return to Green Bay was reminiscent of an exiled leader returning to resume his rightful position.
But,as Benazir Bhutto and Benigno Acquino show us, sometimes the existing powers cap the returning hero.
Incredibly, that seems to be what is happening to Favre. Now the reports are that McCarthy acknowledges that Favre gives the team the best chance to win in the short term, but their eyes are on the future. As I have said before, that makes sense only if you think that you don't have the talent to go deep into the playoffs now. When you have won 18 of the last 22, that doesn't look like the most rational assumption. In the NFL, you win when you can.
This is, I think, the third time that I have blogged this, but, having watched most of the scrimmage on Sunday night, Thompson and McCarthy appear to be absolutely out of their minds. The only way that they survive this is if Favre goes someplace else and stinks or Rodgers leads them deep into the playoffs. They obviously don't think that the former would happen - they are scared to death to let him play elsewhere - and, based on the limited evidence presented Sunday night, the latter seems extremely unlikely. Rodgers short game is extremely inaccurate (a big liability with a team that lives on yards after the catch), his reads are poor and he has nervous feet in the pocket.
He might - he probably will - get better but I don't expect to be buying playoff tickets this year.
And I don't expect to find Ted Thompson or Mike McCarthy in Green Bay a year from now.
But,as Benazir Bhutto and Benigno Acquino show us, sometimes the existing powers cap the returning hero.
Incredibly, that seems to be what is happening to Favre. Now the reports are that McCarthy acknowledges that Favre gives the team the best chance to win in the short term, but their eyes are on the future. As I have said before, that makes sense only if you think that you don't have the talent to go deep into the playoffs now. When you have won 18 of the last 22, that doesn't look like the most rational assumption. In the NFL, you win when you can.
This is, I think, the third time that I have blogged this, but, having watched most of the scrimmage on Sunday night, Thompson and McCarthy appear to be absolutely out of their minds. The only way that they survive this is if Favre goes someplace else and stinks or Rodgers leads them deep into the playoffs. They obviously don't think that the former would happen - they are scared to death to let him play elsewhere - and, based on the limited evidence presented Sunday night, the latter seems extremely unlikely. Rodgers short game is extremely inaccurate (a big liability with a team that lives on yards after the catch), his reads are poor and he has nervous feet in the pocket.
He might - he probably will - get better but I don't expect to be buying playoff tickets this year.
And I don't expect to find Ted Thompson or Mike McCarthy in Green Bay a year from now.
Caleb Richard Esenberg
was born last night at 7:11 pm at St. Joe's. He is 20.5 inches and 9 lbs, 2 oz. Here he is with Dad (aka Shark, Jr.)
And with Mom and big brother Aidan
With Aidan and a guy they'll tell him to call Bampa Teeny (don't ask).
And again with Aidan
And with the whole family
Now that I've indulged myself, political name calling and ruminations on the law will continue forthwith.
A reality check
Greg Sisk at Mirror of Justice collects some interesting statistics on governemnt spending and, in particular, on government spending on social programs. Essentially - and this is nothing new - it turns out that the trend in social spending as a percentage of national income has moved steadily upward while spending on defense has moved steadily downward. Government spending consumes 35.9% of gross domestic product and taxes are the largest single expenditure for the average taxpayer.
Of course, this doesn't tell us what the optimum amount of government spending ought to be and it is important to note that social spending, as he has defined, is not limited to spending on poor people. Welfare spending, which does not include all spending on the poor, seems to have increased from about 2% of GDP in 1960 to 4.4% in 2007 and then declined to around 3% in 2007. On the other hand, the poverty rate has been, roughly, cut in half during that same period. Although all of that reduction seems to have been achieved by 1973 (and most of that, incidentally, before the impact of Great Society programs) and has been stubborn since then (it's actually a bit higher today), the rate of poverty now seems to respond - within a fairly narrow band - to economic growth.
Sisk's point, and mine, is that reality belies some of the overwrought rhetoric about the United States being a "mean" nation and the conservative ascendency having starved public programs. Perhaps we ought to spend more but its not because we have been spending less.
Of course, this doesn't tell us what the optimum amount of government spending ought to be and it is important to note that social spending, as he has defined, is not limited to spending on poor people. Welfare spending, which does not include all spending on the poor, seems to have increased from about 2% of GDP in 1960 to 4.4% in 2007 and then declined to around 3% in 2007. On the other hand, the poverty rate has been, roughly, cut in half during that same period. Although all of that reduction seems to have been achieved by 1973 (and most of that, incidentally, before the impact of Great Society programs) and has been stubborn since then (it's actually a bit higher today), the rate of poverty now seems to respond - within a fairly narrow band - to economic growth.
Sisk's point, and mine, is that reality belies some of the overwrought rhetoric about the United States being a "mean" nation and the conservative ascendency having starved public programs. Perhaps we ought to spend more but its not because we have been spending less.
Sunday, August 03, 2008
Olde Folk Rock
One of my favorite Burkean rock songs is "My Back Pages." If you're interested I can explain why, but consider the refrain along with the these fantastic passages:
In a soldier's stance, I aimed my hand
At the mongrel dogs who teach
Fearing not that I'd become my enemy
In the instant that I preach
Equality," I spoke the word
As if a wedding vow.
Ah, but I was so much older then,
I'm younger than that now.
In any event, here's the song with vocals by its composer Bob Dylan, Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton and George Harrison.
And speaking of the Roger McGuinn and thinking of the Byrds covering Dylan, here are the Byrds performing "Chimes of Freedom" at the 1967 Monterey Pop Festival:
In a soldier's stance, I aimed my hand
At the mongrel dogs who teach
Fearing not that I'd become my enemy
In the instant that I preach
Equality," I spoke the word
As if a wedding vow.
Ah, but I was so much older then,
I'm younger than that now.
In any event, here's the song with vocals by its composer Bob Dylan, Roger McGuinn, Tom Petty, Neil Young, Eric Clapton and George Harrison.
And speaking of the Roger McGuinn and thinking of the Byrds covering Dylan, here are the Byrds performing "Chimes of Freedom" at the 1967 Monterey Pop Festival:
Some wisdom from Justice David Prosser
Very interesting language from Justice David Prosser, concurring in a decision that denied a motion to vacate an earlier decision of the Court, holding that an attorney named Bob Donohoo should be sanctioned for filing a frivolous defamation action action against Action Wisconsin, an organization promoting the rights and pertinent policy preferences of gays and lesbians. Donohoo argued that Butler was disqualified because he had not disclosed contributions from board members of Action Wisconsin (now known as Fair Wisconsin) and had appeared at a fundraiser for a PAC promoting the same issues as Fair Wisconsin and that later endorsed him. Butler also received (although he had disclosed) contributions from Action Wisconsin's attorneys, one of whom wrote an op-ed endorsing his candidacy for the Court.
I think that the Court got the original decision wrong. As I blogged at the time he was initially sanctioned, I would not have brought the case that Donohoo did because - putting aside whatever one thinks of his client who seems pretty unsympathetic - I don't believe that the likelihood of success for the client would have been worth the effort. But, in my mind, that's not the same as a claim being frivolous. I don't think that the statute forbidding such claims was intended to prohibit lawyers and parties from taking a long shot. There just has to be some real chance of prevailing and I think there was in the case that he brought. If I had been the judge, I think I would have dismissed it but I wouldn't have sanctioned him.
But the Court was right to deny his motion to vacate. Justice Butler was not disqualified from hearing the case. It was an ideologically charged matter. It's not surprising that people who are political liberals were associated in some way with Action Wisconsin. It's not surprising that some of those same political liberals would contribute to Justice Butler's campaign. To argue that a justice is disqualified as a matter of law in such cases would be to frustrate the will of the voters (and, in the case of an appointed justice who has not yet faced election, the Governor) who, under our state constitution, have the right to determine the composition of the court. Respecting that right means, I think, that Justices should recuse themselves (or be disqualified) only for the starkest conflicts or when the Justice herself believes that she cannot be open minded.
Justice Prosser takes aim at the pressure currently being brought to bear upon Justices and observes that it presents a danger that they will recuse themselves when they ought not to do so.
He then fires this shot across the bow of those who believe that judicial elections have become overly politicized:
¶62 It is entirely reasonable to have a dispassionate discussion on the role of public funding in judicial campaigns. But people who care about the judiciary must also look long and hard at why supreme court elections have become so contentious and expensive.
¶63 A court that is in the vanguard of making and changing law in a way that greatly benefits some interest groups and seriously damages others is a court that is actively, if inadvertently, promoting the politicization of its own elections. Every litigant believes he is entitled to an impartial review of his case. If litigants do not believe they can get an impartial review of their cases, they will inevitably attempt to change the composition of the court.
I think that the Court got the original decision wrong. As I blogged at the time he was initially sanctioned, I would not have brought the case that Donohoo did because - putting aside whatever one thinks of his client who seems pretty unsympathetic - I don't believe that the likelihood of success for the client would have been worth the effort. But, in my mind, that's not the same as a claim being frivolous. I don't think that the statute forbidding such claims was intended to prohibit lawyers and parties from taking a long shot. There just has to be some real chance of prevailing and I think there was in the case that he brought. If I had been the judge, I think I would have dismissed it but I wouldn't have sanctioned him.
But the Court was right to deny his motion to vacate. Justice Butler was not disqualified from hearing the case. It was an ideologically charged matter. It's not surprising that people who are political liberals were associated in some way with Action Wisconsin. It's not surprising that some of those same political liberals would contribute to Justice Butler's campaign. To argue that a justice is disqualified as a matter of law in such cases would be to frustrate the will of the voters (and, in the case of an appointed justice who has not yet faced election, the Governor) who, under our state constitution, have the right to determine the composition of the court. Respecting that right means, I think, that Justices should recuse themselves (or be disqualified) only for the starkest conflicts or when the Justice herself believes that she cannot be open minded.
Justice Prosser takes aim at the pressure currently being brought to bear upon Justices and observes that it presents a danger that they will recuse themselves when they ought not to do so.
He then fires this shot across the bow of those who believe that judicial elections have become overly politicized:
¶62 It is entirely reasonable to have a dispassionate discussion on the role of public funding in judicial campaigns. But people who care about the judiciary must also look long and hard at why supreme court elections have become so contentious and expensive.
¶63 A court that is in the vanguard of making and changing law in a way that greatly benefits some interest groups and seriously damages others is a court that is actively, if inadvertently, promoting the politicization of its own elections. Every litigant believes he is entitled to an impartial review of his case. If litigants do not believe they can get an impartial review of their cases, they will inevitably attempt to change the composition of the court.
Saturday, August 02, 2008
Obama the Magnificent?
So what do we think of the McCain spots making fun of Obama's celebrity? I suspect that they are in response to Obama's trip overseas. My guess is that polling and focus groups show that Obama and his media camp followers went too far and the idea that Obama and his supporters have gone over the top resonates.
Obama supporters have pointed to the enthusiasm that their candidate generates as some type of endorsement - or confirmation - of the notion that he should be the President. Look at all the young people! Look at how they love him in Europe! What enthusiasm in the black community! It was Obama, and not McCain, who first ran spots with that creepy Obama chant and it is Obama, not McCain, who seems committed to providing his critics with ridiculously overdrawn rhetoric with, I'm sorry, eschatological overtones.
The best way to respond to that may be to make fun of it. But there is also a serious message here. Obama is extraordinarily new and inexperienced for a man running for President. There is also a concerted lack of substance in much of what he says. Personally, I think Obama is a garden variety left liberal - maybe even a bit on the extreme side by American standards. But,save for the occasional gaffe, that is not how he's running the race. Given recent political history, that's understandable, but it contributes to the sense that we don't know what we are getting.
Obama supporters have pointed to the enthusiasm that their candidate generates as some type of endorsement - or confirmation - of the notion that he should be the President. Look at all the young people! Look at how they love him in Europe! What enthusiasm in the black community! It was Obama, and not McCain, who first ran spots with that creepy Obama chant and it is Obama, not McCain, who seems committed to providing his critics with ridiculously overdrawn rhetoric with, I'm sorry, eschatological overtones.
The best way to respond to that may be to make fun of it. But there is also a serious message here. Obama is extraordinarily new and inexperienced for a man running for President. There is also a concerted lack of substance in much of what he says. Personally, I think Obama is a garden variety left liberal - maybe even a bit on the extreme side by American standards. But,save for the occasional gaffe, that is not how he's running the race. Given recent political history, that's understandable, but it contributes to the sense that we don't know what we are getting.
Blogging Problems
Blogger locked my site for a few days because it's robots thought it was a spam blog. I suspect that some around here might agree. I also understand that folks who use IE 7 are unable to open sites that have installed sitemeter. You can apparently resolve that by adding *://*.sitemeter.com to your restricted site (under tools/internet options/security/restricted websites/websites). The other option is for the blog to remove sitemeter although I'm not entirely sure how to do it. I can remove it from my layout but what about old pages? First, I have to decide whether to stay with Blogger.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)