Tuesday, August 05, 2008

San Diego is a great place to protest

I am, notwithstanding the fact that I am old enough for my wonderful children to have wonderful children (but just barely!), new to full time employment as a legal academic. One of the things that comes with such employment is the opportunity to attend the annual meeting of the American Association of Law Schools (AALS) typically held in early January, between semesters. My first AALS meeting was last January in New York. I had a great time. Marquette hosted a reception with a chocolate fountain and blue and gold martinis. There was a great party at the Rainbow Room. Conservative profs met in the catacombs.

This academic year, the meeting is headquartered in San Diego (the Reddess approves!),and the main hotel is owned by a guy - devout Catholic - who has contributed to the referendum to ban same sex marriage in California. Certain sections of the AALS and of, there is no other way to describe it, anachronistic New Left organization known as the Society of American Law Teachers, want the AALS to move the meeting. If it doesn't, they say they won't attend events there. boycott the hotel. There is no allegation that the hotel discriminates on the basis of sexual orientation.

Of course, people can refuse to do business with persons whose politics they don't like. There are very few jurisdictions that prohibit discrimination on political grounds and such bans are, in my view, constitutionally suspect.

But this ups the political ante in a way that hampers civil discourse. Same sex marriage is something that, until very recently, few people had ever thought of. Now, in the view of some, opposition to it - for whatever reason - is so odious that opponents ought to be read out of civil society.

It reflects, I think, a desire to totalize politics. Robert Araujo, writing at Mirror of Justice, quotes Christopher Dawson's observation that the totalitarian state "is not satisfied with passive obedience; it demands full co-operation from the cradle to the grave… "

I find it particularly odd that legal scholars would take such a position. Would those who want to boycott the hotel walk out of panels including those who oppose same sex marriage or believe that the few cases that have found it to be constitutionally mandated were wrongly decided?

In the end, though, Orin Kerr at the Volokh Conspiracy may have the best take on this. "Whoever thought up a boycott that requires you to be in San Diego in January," he writes, "but forbids you to attend the panels has a keen sense of how to appeal to the academic mind."

Or to human nature in general.


Anonymous said...

I just read the other day that 1768fires were set by lightening in California shortly after the California Supreme Court legalized gay marriage or whatever kind of marriage you want.

I think lightening strikes are called acts of God. Perhaps they should take up their protest with Him.

Anonymous said...

Liberal lawyers are as useless as teats on a bull.
Let them boycott the guys hotel.
I'm sure he won't miss them.

Anonymous said...


Apologies for posting this as a comment - I couldn't find an email address or contact form.

This is just a quick courtesy note to let you know that your blog has been included as a Trusted Source on the Politigg.us political news site:

This means that Politigg.us will provide a direct link to every article you write from now on, including a brief snippet to get readers interested. You can keep track of all your articles here:

Politigg aims to allow you access to the best political articles from across the web, as judged by other members. Also, you can use it to follow all of your favorite political blogs in one place, bookmark useful articles and use the tags system to find all articles on a particular topic.

To get the most out of Politigg.us, I strongly advise you to read the one page Quick Start User Guide which covers all the main functions.

Suggestions for new blogs, news sites and political groups to include in the Trusted Sources list are most welcome.

If you would like to link to Politigg.us, there is a range of buttons and text links available, including a Trusted Source button, here:

Or, you can add a voting widget to each of your articles:


Anthony Butcher